Cartridge Choice Philosophy
One of the most common enquiries we receive is
'What cartridge should I use with this arm/deck? We have reduced
the massive list of options as much as possible by offering tried
and tested cartridges that work in the vast majority of
systems. These have been selected from both personal experience
and the opinions of trusted dealers and reviewers. You can be
sure
these offer above average performance and excellent value for money.
Although making specific recommendations we still
offer most makes of hi fi cartridge so that you can order any brand
from us direct. Details and specifications of phono cartridges
are
provided on separate pages (see links). Our hot list of audio cartridges
shown below, include many audiophile models chosen for
performance and flexibility. These cartridges all
come highly recommended by those with wide experience.
All prices include 17.5% VAT so deduct this for
export orders.
NOTE on abbreviations
mm = moving magnet cartridge with high output and 47 Kohm impedance
mc = moving coil cartridge with low output usually and 100 ohm impedance
A number of the high output moving coils use moving magnet input
at 47 Kohms
Cheap cartridges?
There are sources that offer seemingly amazing prices on cartridges
- we would urge caution on these purchases as you may not
know what you are getting. For example some Kouetsu's are made
specifically for the Far East market. These Kouetsu's have a suspension
system suited for hot climates and will not give optimum performance
in colder climates.
HOT LIST OF CARTRIDGES WITH STRONG RECOMMENDATION
It is quite hard nowadays to purchase a "duff" cartridge
so the choice boils down to personal taste, compatibility and system
matching. For this reason we can only offer guidelines on which
cartridge to choose because sometimes it is a question of synergy.
The first question is moving coil or moving magnet? Ultimately
low output moving coil cartridges deliver the best performance but
you need a decent active phono stage (around £300 and above)
to really get the benefit. A lower cost alternative is moving magnet
or high output moving coil - these can deliver fine performance
into a wide variety of phono stages although we would recommend
a minimum of the GSP Gram 1 phono stage at £85.
Higher end cartridges
High end cartridges such as koetsu, Lyra, Clearaudio, Microbenz,
Van den Hul transfiguration etc all have their various strengths
and reviews help to clarify your choice depending on your system
and priorities. We particularly recommend the Lyra cartridge range
but there are many other excellent cartridges which will work as
well depending on your system and phono stage balance.
Mid market cartridges
The Dynavector Karat 17d2 mkII is a moving coil cartridge at £550
and represents great value for money. The Lyra Dorian has also gained
and excellent reputation and a safe choice.
If you do not have a reasonable moving coil phono stage with adjustable
gain settings (above
£300) then the Music Maker cartridge at £575 by "The
cartridge man" is almost legendry as a moving magnet design.
Cartridges below £250
The high output moving coil Dynavector DV10x5 II
at 250 GBP is a truly superb cartridge in any arm and is designed
for most moving magnet inputs - this cartridge has consistently
been reviewed as the best available at this price point.
The Goldring 1000 Series starts at £80
GBP - we particularly recommend the Goldring 1042 mm cartridge at
£150
The Low output Goldring Eroica cartridge at 130 GBP are excellent
for a budget moving coil cartridge and in our view the low output
Eroica LX is slightly preferable to the 1042 if you have a decent
moving coil stage.
The Grado prestige range mm cartridges starting
at £40 are also excellent - these cartridges have a slightly
better bass than the Goldrings but not quite such a good treble
performance.
Please see our web site shop for all prices and quotes on delivery
charge etc.
Remarks on the sound character of various cartridge makes
Cartridges marked with an * are the ideal choice for Origin Live
tonearms. However this is only a rough guide as speakers, amps and
phono-stage also play a part in the best choice of cartridge for
your system. The remarks below are by no means definitive and are
only intended as a guide to help those in no position to audition
the multitude of options available.
* Audio Technica OC9 £ 330 GBP
(or £ 250 GBP exchange)- noted for definition, speed, clarity
and detail - can be a little lean in the bass in some arms - seems
most suited on Linn LP12 / Ittock or Akito combinations. The budget
Audio Technica's are extremely good value.
* Clearaudio - very clean sounding catridge, highly
detailed, not exactly warm or deep.
* Dynavector - Excellent all round mc cartridges
- high output versions are 10x5 and 20XH suitable for moving magnet
inputs, low outputs are also available higher in the range.
Dynavector 17D Karat is a favourite at its price point. The xx-2
seems rather system dependent.
* Goldring - Rich sound with plenty of warmth
and bass depth - a popular phono cartridge with Rega arm users -
a very safe choice that sounds good on most systems.
* Koetsu - Great all round cartridges that deliver
an integrated portrayal along with great sense of power and authoritative
bass. Sound slightly "thick"and less free in comparison
to "zyx cartridges".
* Lyra - Great tacking cartridges that deliver
an organic presentation - may not go quite as deep as Koetsus or
have the same bass warmth but have the edge in other
aspects such as transparency and imaging.
Rega cartridges - Tend to work well with Rega
decks but can sound dull on other makes.
Reson - Similar to the Goldring but added definition
due to closer tolerances (made by Goldring). The Reson cartridges
are good if your system has a lot of bass and you like high resolution
with a nice top end. There is a slight loss of bass warmth relative
to the Goldring 1000 series.
* Grado cartridges are excellent on bass and
midband - in treble shy systems they can sound slightly dull.
Sumiko - A good choice for systems that are slightly
bass heavy and need speed and agility adding - these cartridges
have great resolution and are improved over previous models that
tended to be lean in deep bass and low in warmth for some systems
* Transfiguration - Good all round cartridge and
a very safe choice, strong on subtlety with wonderful delicacy rather
than an emphasis on hard hitting and impact.
* Zyx - Very good tonal balance with slight emphasis
on dynamic and deep bass. One of the most natural sounding mid bands
available, excellent clarity and seperation of instruments, sweet
top end without the explicitness or slight overemphasis of some
high end contenders.
Please contact us to place an order or obtain a quote on the pick
up cartridge of your choice
Cartridge matching
Most cartridges will be compatible with modern tonearms even those
well outside the theoretical ideal effective mass. For medium
mass arms a compliance of 10 - 15 x10-6 cm/dyne is ideal.
Exchange cartridges - (your current cartridge has expired or been
damaged)
If you have a cartridge that is damaged or simply come to the end
of its recommended life (normaly 2000 - 3000 hours of play). There
are several options.
a) Trade it in for an exchange cartridge from the same
manufacturer - generaly you get between 20 to 25% of the
value of the cartridge you send in, offset against the cost of the
new cartridge whether it''s a direct replacement or a trade up to
a better model.
b) Purchase a new stylus - this is usually only
a small saving on an exchange cartridge and not worth it in our
view unless your cartridge is very new and only has a bent cantilever.
The reason is that once a cartridge has had a lot of use the inside
gets gunged up with debris. Most companies do not offer a new stylus
option.
c) Purchase a new cartridge - this is often the
best option. Cartridges are advancing in quality steadily and older
designs are sometimes poor value in comparison even on an exchange
basis.
d) Get the cartridge repaired or retipped by a specialist
company - this option will usually be a minimum of £150
but often seems very attractive for more expensive cartridges. It
should be carefully noted however that you are highly unlikely to
get back a cartridge close to the original. The parts used in rebuilds
are rarely from the original manufacturer or of the same specifications.
For this reason it is a slightly dubious path although some owners
have been pleased with the results. Retipping can be worthwhile
providing the catridge insides can be cleaned thoroughly and the
cantilever suspension is still in good condition. We provide no
further advice on this subject so please do not ask us, neither
do we give out the names of companies that offer this service for
various reasons.
|